← All Resources Claims Processing Optimization

Five Questions to Ask Before Your Next IDR Arbitration

By Netmark Team
Health plan manager reviewing an arbitration checklist

Providers filed about 2.56 million IDR disputes in 2025, and they prevailed in roughly 85 to 88 percent of the ones decided. Plans that want a different result do not need a bigger intake team. They need a better file. These five questions test whether yours is ready, and show where Netmark's Clinical Shield fits.

Why the clinical opinion matters more than the volume

Most of the cost in IDR is set before an arbitrator reads a word. Provider offers have run 5 to 10 times the plan's qualifying payment amount (QPA), so each lost dispute pays out far more than the plan's own benchmark. The plan's only way to narrow that gap is the quality of what it puts on the record.

A strong record has two parts: the payment evidence most plans already assemble, and a clinical position that most do not. The questions below concentrate on the second part.

1. Who is speaking for the plan on the clinical question?

When a provider argues that a case was unusually complex, the argument is medical. If the plan's reply is a fee schedule and a QPA calculation, nobody has answered the medical point. Clinical Shield adds a credentialed clinical reviewer to the file, and a board-certified physician on the disputes that carry the most dollars.

2. Does every dispute deserve the same level of review?

It does not, and treating them alike wastes either money or leverage. Clinical Shield works in three tiers:

  • Tier 1, RN Clinical Screen: an RN with a coding credential scores complexity and flags coding and eligibility problems on every dispute.
  • Tier 2, Clinical Evidence Brief: an RN-authored brief, signed off by a board-certified physician, that answers the provider's complexity claim on mid-value cases.
  • Tier 3, Sub-Specialty Opinion: a signed opinion from a board-certified physician in the billing provider's own specialty, reserved for high-dollar or contestable cases.

Physician hours go where they can change an outcome.

3. Will the evidence exist while the offer can still move?

A strong clinical rebuttal delivered after the offer is locked has little value. Clinical Shield returns its findings during negotiation, through an API or file exchange with your IDR platform, one case at a time or in batches. It runs alongside IDRIQ, Netmark's IDR cost containment platform, or alongside the workflow you already use. In complex cases, Clinical Shield will acquire medical records from the provider as supporting evidence for specialist review and opinion.

4. Can you name the person behind the opinion?

An arbitrator can weigh an opinion more heavily when a named physician stands behind it. Every Tier 2 and Tier 3 deliverable carries a physician's signature, and the documentation is built for the scrutiny of formal arbitration.

5. Where does AI help, and who is accountable for the result?

Netmark uses AI for two jobs: routing complex DRG cases to the appropriate tier, and summarizing medical records so reviewers can start from the substance. The clinical judgment stays with people. The physician signs, and the physician owns the opinion.

A quick readiness check

Use this table with your IDR team. Each answer of no points to a gap that Clinical Shield addresses.

If the answer is noWhat closes the gap
No clinical rebuttal on fileA credentialed clinical reviewer on every dispute, a physician on the largest
Same review effort on every caseThree tiers that scale review depth to the dispute
Evidence arrives after the offerFindings delivered during negotiation by API or file exchange
No named expert behind the opinionA signed opinion from a board-certified physician
AI use is unclear or unaccountableAI for routing and record summaries, physicians for the judgment

See it on your own disputes

If you could not answer all five questions with confidence, a pilot is a low-risk way to close the gaps. A pilot has three parts:

  • You send: a defined set of current disputes, including a mix of values.
  • Netmark returns: a review of each case at the tier that fits, with the clinical documentation that goes with it.
  • You judge: how the result compares with the file your team would have built on its own.

To scope a pilot, contact Jay Antani, VP of Health Plan Solutions, Netmark Services.

Ready to optimize your claims operations?

Connect With Netmark